The World Of Sports Viewed Through The Eyes Of A Yankees And Red Sox Fan

Tuesday, June 26, 2012

Harper vs. Trout; Who's More Important?


By: Mike Wagenman
Two of the best young players in the major leagues are, without a doubt, Bryce Harper of the Nationals and Mike Trout of the Angels.  They are 19 and 20, respectively, and arguably have more potential than almost any prospect in the past decade.  While Harper’s every at-bat is national news, Trout is somehow flying under the radar out in California and seems undeservingly overshadowed.  Arguing over who is the better player between the two is like splitting hairs, and it is much too early on in their careers.  However, I posed the question “who is more important to the success of his respective team?” on Twitter a few days back, and got some mixed responses.  Here is a closer look.
Since being called up on April 28th and debuting against the Dodgers, Harper is hitting .280 with seven home runs, 20 RBI and a .361 on-base percentage.  All very stellar numbers for a rookie indeed.  However, the Nationals were 14-6 before Harper was added to the major league roster and are just 27-24 since.  Although it is still early, the Nats’ record does not indicate extreme benefit from Harper’s presence.  Some benefit, yes.  Harper also seems to be in the midst of a rookie slump; it looks as though opposing pitchers are figuring him out, as evident by his 0-7 with five strikeouts performance in a 14-inning loss to the Yankees.  He is hitting just .186 with an on-base percentage of .255 and 14 strikeouts in his past 11 games.  In those 11 games, Harper has not hit a home run and has only driven in one run. 
With Michael Morse and Ryan Zimmerman limited by injury, Adam LaRoche coming back down to earth, and the role players playing average at best, Washington has been counting on their 19-year-old outfielder to put the team on his shoulders and make his teammates better.  It is a tall task for anyone, let alone a rookie.  It is also no secret that the Nationals are driven by their pitching, with a league best 2.97 ERA and .220 batting average against.  Judging by the numbers and trends, it seems that the Nationals pitching is more beneficial than Harper.
On the flip side of the coin in Los Angeles/Anaheim, the Angels’ rookie has done nothing short of carrying his team.  Trout is leading the American League with a .338 batting average.  In just 51 games at the big league level, compared to around 70 for most other regular starters, Trout is first in stolen bases (21), sixth in OPS (.931), third in on-base percentage (.399), as told by Jake Dal Porto of Bustasports.  He is the leadoff man for the Angels, and is a true catalyst at the top of the lineup.  Opposing pitchers and catchers have been concerned about Trout on the bases, usually leading to mistakes, hits, and runs for the Angels. 
The Angels were a lowly 6-14 before Trout was called up, but are 32-19 since and have gained five games on the division leading Rangers.  While Harper is still a work-in-progress in the outfield, Trout is a legitimate Gold Glove candidate in the outfield.  He has just one error, and uses his speed to cover an incredible amount of ground.  He has made driving, running, and jumping catches all season long, saving runs for his team.  Trout’s constant presence on the bases has lead to a higher batting average for his teammates like Torii Hunter, Albert Pujols, Kendrys Morales, and Mark Trumbo, most of who were struggling to start the year.  Trout has proven to be a game-changer, and a guy that drives the Angel offense.
Although Bryce Harper has an infinite amount of talent and potential, it is clear that Mike Trout has done far more for his team.  Yet, somehow he still does not get the recognition he deserves.  His speed, hitting, and defense change games for Los Angeles.  Tune in to watch Harper and the Nationals take on the Rockies at 8:40 PM ET and Trout and the Angels take on the Orioles at 7:05 PM ET.

Sources: ESPN, Bustasports, SweetSpot Network

No comments:

Post a Comment